Archive for the 'Sun' Category

Oracle Sun Acquisition Musings

A little time has past since the announcement that Oracle would acquire Sun. While there are still many unanswered questions, I thought I’d post a quick update on the topic.

The first topic I’ll cover is the Sun hardware business. From a recent interview with Larry (via Ostatic):

“No, we are definitely not going to exit the hardware business. While most hardware businesses are low-margin, companies like Apple and Cisco enjoy very high-margins because they do a good job of designing their hardware and software to work together. If a company designs both hardware and software, it can build much better systems than if they only design the software. That’s why Apple’s iPhone is so much better than Microsoft phones.”

Ellison also confirms in the interview that far from discontinuing the SPARC chip, he intends to increase investment in it. “We think designing our own chips is very, very important,” he said. He also notes that Sun outsources almost all of its manufacturing to companies such as Fujitsu.

So it looks like Oracle will indeed be pursuing the “entire stack” path that many predicted. One major benefit to Oracle here is that if a customer is getting both their hardware and software (including both the OS and applications) from the same company, it makes switching away from that company extremely costly and complicated.

That brings us to the OS. It’s still not clear to me which way Oracle is going to go here. Long term I can’t see Solaris and Linux being first class citizens within Oracle. Which one they choose remains to be seen. They “own” Solaris in a way they could never “own” Linux, which may be the deciding factor for a company like Oracle. That being said, I’d imagine more of their customers want Linux so it’s certainly not going to be an easy decision. Some are speculating (via Matt) that if Oracle does go with Solaris that a company like IBM may acquire Red Hat. I’m not so sure about that, but it is a possibility. While IBM does really like Linux, Jboss would be a major duplication for IBM (and it represents a lot of the growth potential within Red Hat).

Finally, here’s a recent announcement regarding MySQL:

The following was in the just released monthly bug report for the Falcon storage engine:

“With the news that Sun has aggreed to be purchaced by Oracle, Some inevitable changes will occur. Once the acquisition is made, the need for Falcon as a MySQL storage engine will be re-evaluated. Until then, Falcon will continue to improve stability and performance. The team will also evaluate other technical niches that may be unique to Falcon.”

I for one would be very disappointed to see Falcon not supported by Oracle. I know they have worked very hard to create a next-generation storage engine. While it could be argued that InnoDB can fill all use cases, I believe that choices are a good thing and having one less choice is not a good thing.

Good luck all on the team. You have been nothing but kind and generous when answering my dumb questions via email and in person. You can count my vote for “keep it!!”.

I think it’s clear that this acquisition will mean some significant changes for the future path of MySQL. The fact that a lot of upcoming MySQL-related innovation may come from outside the company, and from places like the Open Database Alliance should at least ensure that MySQL remains viable from a technology standpoint.

–jeremy

  • Share/Bookmark

Oracle Agrees to Acquire Sun Microsystems

With rumors of an IBM acquisition still swirling, early this morning Oracle announced that it is acquiring Sun for roughly $7.4 billion. From a CNET article:

Oracle and Sun announced Monday that they have entered into a definitive agreement under which Oracle will acquire Sun common stock for $9.50 per share in cash. That puts the value of the transaction at about $7.4 billion, or $5.6 billion net of Sun’s cash and debt.

Oracle President Safra Catz said in a statement:

We expect this acquisition to be accretive to Oracle’s earnings by at least 15 cents on a non-GAAP basis in the first full year after closing. We estimate that the acquired business will contribute over $1.5 billion to Oracle’s non-GAAP operating profit in the first year, increasing to over $2 billion in the second year. This would make the Sun acquisition more profitable in per share contribution in the first year than we had planned for the acquisitions of BEA, PeopleSoft and Siebel combined.

To me, IBM seems like a better fit for Sun and this acquisition leaves as many questions as answers. While Oracle recently announced a hardware product line in a partnership with HP, do they really want to be in the hardware business themselves? A few years ago Larry Ellison definitively said they did not want to be in that business. With much of Sun’s revenue coming from hardware, will they spin that division off or use it to focus more on a complete Oracle stack, that includes everything from hardware to database. Moving to the individual parts of that stack, will Oracle continue with the Sparc CPU line or be interested in the more commodity x86 lines. At the OS level, will Oracle continue to focus on Linux and their Unbreakable implementation or will they attempt to keep Solaris alive. Oracle has been contributing to Linux in a significant way recently, and it would be a huge loss for that to go away IMHO. At the recent Linux Foundation summit Oracle touted that it views it’s upcoming btrfs filesystem as superior to ZFS. What does the future hold for projects such as that?

That brings us to MySQL. I’d contend that MySQL is “worth” more to Oracle than it is to any other company (including IBM) and here’s why. To most other companies, MySQL is roughly worth the net present value of future projected MySQL revenue. The thing most people don’t understand about the MySQL/Oracle relationship is that for many small to medium commercial projects, MySQL is “good enough” and has a much lower TCO than Oracle. Even so, many companies didn’t actually want to go with MySQL for a variety of reasons (many political and procurement related). This created a situation where the *option* of MySQL effectively capped the price people would spend on low end Oracle projects. It wasn’t just the number of people actually leaving Oracle for MySQL, it was the number threatening to and getting additional (and sometimes steep) discounts on Oracle as a result. This creates a premium to Oracle that no other company would have been able to extract. What this acquisition means for the long term future of MySQL within Sun is unclear to me. Oracle has owned InnoDB for a long time. This could either be a long overdue reunion of Inno and MySQL, or the beginning of a slow death for MySQL. One where Oracle doesn’t overtly kill the project, but deprecates any features it sees as threating to its main cash cow and relegates MySQL to a web-only type product. On a related note, the acquisition almost certainly means the end of Postgres support within Sun.

It seems one piece that will certainly benefit from the acquisition is Java, although I’d imagine that IBM is not too happy that Oracle now “owns” Java. Eclipse might have to change it’s name now ;) Also, the rivalry between Larry and Bill Gates is well known. Does this mean that Oracle will be interested in funding addition OpenOffice.org development even thought it’s *way* outside their normal target market?

In the end, Oracle is one of the best acquisition machines on the plant. They have been purchasing and integrating companies for a long time. They’ve become very good at it. However, most of the companies they have acquired have been very specific targets in niche markets that aimed to fill a perceived gap in Oracle’s offerings. Sun is not that. They are a huge company with a massive product line that spans hardware and software. This is not the average Oracle acquisition and the decisions Oracle makes will have massive implications not just for Open Source but for the entire IT industry.

–jeremy

(Note: Interestingly, the Oracle press site has been down with a “Server is too busy to handle request” for the last 30 minutes. I’ll update the first link in this post as soon as it’s back up. Until then, here’s a NYT article.)

[Updated] Additional links:

Glyn Moody
Matt Asay
Larry Augustin

  • Share/Bookmark

Roundtable Discussion: Why Can’t We All Just Get Along (Liveblog)

Panelists:
Jim Zemlin – Linux Foundation
Ian Murdock – Sun
Sam Ramji – Microsoft

* Lessons learned after being at MSFT for a couple years as the “Open Source” guy
– Sam: When he came in from BEA, things working together “just made sense” to him. Day 1 he would have explained what he was doing a bit better to the legal team. Engineers tend to change much quicker than lawyers, whose job is to mitigate risk.
* Similar question to Ian:
– Was a bit of a culture shock going to Sun. He was used to working at 50+ person companies that he had started. Thinks he may have been a bit naive when first going into Sun. “Large companies have more inertia than you might think”.

* It’s clear that Microsoft sees the computing landscape changing. What can the Open Source crowds do to help the agents of change within the company?
– Sam: We’re a large company and some parts are changing faster than others. Identifying that there is a place to go with the things you think are not going well is important. He’d like to be seen as the unelected representative within Microsoft for us. He might not have an immediate answer, but he wants to better understand the problems.

* Why does he (Sam) care what the Open Source and Linux communities think?
Sam the person: “I think computing just needs to get better”
Sam the MSFT representative: We’re at a point in our history that we need to understand what the next engine of growth is going to be.

* What is Sun going to do with MySQL?
– Ian: We’ve fully committed to the Open Source model. MySQL represents a huge opportunity. The kinds of software you see being used in Web 2.0 and cloud computing represent a new dynamic. Sun’s global sales force plus products like MySQL are where Sun will grow.

* Where is Microsoft going next?
– Sam: We want to build software that is in demand on every platform. He sees 4 general directions for this: server, client, mobile and cloud.

* Sam: “When you hear the same thing from enough customers, you listen…even if you don’t necessarily agree”. Gave the example of Microsoft supporting PHP, despite having put a lot of resources toward and really liking ASP.NET.

* We’re clearly disappointed about Software Patents in this community. The recent FAT lawsuit included.
– Sam: We agree there are issues, but don’t think the whole system should just be thrown out. Says Microsoft suffers more than anyone else in the current system. Spends over $100M a year defending against patent suits. Did not address FAT lawsuit specifically.
Ian: It’s a bit of an arms race and large companies feel the need to amass patents for defensive reasons. No one wants to be the first to drop all their patents.

* Ian: With cloud computing, are we losing many of the advantages of Open Source?
– Jim: I don’t think the operating system discussion is going to be decided for a while.
– Sam: Now the “cloud” is just elastic computing. The next cloud with be more like Google App Engine or Microsoft Azure. The idioms and structures are different… it’s a whole different environment.
(Note: I don’t think they fully understood the question Ian was asking, but it’s a really important question…and one I’ll be thinking about quite a bit moving forward. It’s not always just about access to the code. It’s about the code being usable outside the original context, portability and other related issues)

* Question from Jeremy Allison: Asserting patent rights is fundamentally against the Open Source ethos. FAT lawsuit aside, Jeremy would simply like clarity around what interoperability IS possible and what interoperability (from a legal perspective) IS NOT possible.
– Sam: We learned a lot from the work MSFT did with Samba on licensing protocols, but it won’t scale to 1,000 of protocols. “We can and must do more about predictability on where we’re going”. Places where we currently have a licensing program are probably good places for Open Source to stay away from, at least in the near future. “We need to improve here”. The SMB/CIFS agreement went through 35 iterations in 6 weeks. We’re willing to learn.

The final consensus: where we can be more clear with each other, let’s do it. Linux, Microsoft and Sun are all going to be around for the long haul. We’re all going to be here, let’s make the best of it. Let’s move beyond ideology and be pragmatic.

That’s the end of the Summit for today. See you at the Exploratorium for the evening reception.

–jeremy

  • Share/Bookmark

The MySQL exodus at Sun

It looks like the exodus of top MySQL execs from Sun is in full swing. Yesterday, Monty posted the following:

Time to move on
I have now departed from Sun and joined my own company, Monty Program Ab.

There were a lot of rumors around me resigning in August/September last year. I didn’t back then want to comment on the rumors, because I was still trying to work something out with Sun. Now I can finally describe a bit of what was going on.

In this case, the rumors had some elements of truth to them. I had told management that I thus would be submitting my resignation immediately as I strongly believed that the 5.1 release was not ready and that those problems needed to be fixed before it went GA. This action, together with other peoples´ efforts, did have the wanted effect and I made an agreement with Sun´s upper management to not initiate my resignation but instead stay around for three more months to help Sun work out things in MySQL Development and also give Sun a chance to create an optimal role for me within Sun.

The three months did stretch out to seven months, and the changes I had hoped Sun would apply to in the MySQL Database group to fix our development and community problems did not happen fast enough.

Sun and I concluded in the end that I have much higher chances of achieving my goals outside of Sun, so it’s just better to swallow the bitter apple, go out and get things going. We parted in good terms and we both expect to continue to do business and work together.

As you probably know, Monty is one of the two co-founders of MySQL AB. The other co-founder, David Axmark, left Sun last year. It’s often the case that founders leave the acquiring company after a little while, so neither of these came as a huge surprise to me. Today, however, we got the news that Marten Mickos is leaving Sun amid a reorg:

I just got news that Marten Mickos, former MySQL CEO, is to depart Sun amid a reorganisation of its infrastructure and database business units. Don’t expect an announcement from Sun on this, but the news is confirmed.

It seems that Sun is combining its Software Infrastructure organization with its Database Group to form a unified open source product group under the leadership of Karen Tegan Padir, vice president of MySQL & Software Infrastructure.

Marten was the long time CEO and really helped MySQL AB grow from a business perspective. Sometimes that growth came at the cost of angering the MySQL community. While founder Monty was a tech guy, Marten was a business guy. To see him leave so soon is much more of a surprise to me. Combined, these three losses are huge for Sun, and may start to raise questions not only about the future of MySQL within Sun… but about the future of Sun in general. Sun has done some very innovative things in the past, but has clearly been going through a bit of a cultural shift internally. I always saw the MySQL AB acquisition as a potential way to help spread the Open Source mantra inside a company that was a bit conflicted. It will be interesting to see how Sun moves forward from here.

–jeremy

  • Share/Bookmark

Tech Vendors That May Not Survive 2009

We all know that the global economy is not doing well right now. Very few days go by without some bad news hitting the wire. This article (if it can be called an “article”… it’s more of a flash presentation) may be a signal that we’re going a bit too far though:

In the Channel Insider 2009 Market Pulse Survey, we asked solution providers which vendors they thought would go out of business or be acquired in 2009. The results may shock you. Based on their perceptions and predictions, the following are the vendors that made the going list of those that won’t be here in 2010.

The list follows:

10. VMWare
9. Symantec
8. Citrix
7. Sun
6. AMD
6. CA
5. Salesforce.com
4. McAfee
3. Checkpoint
2. NetApp
1. Novell

To be honest, I think the downside to the current economic situation is likely to be longer and deeper than many are predicting. To suggest that the companies above, however, will be gone in 11 months is in many cases ludicrous. There are a couple of them that could survive that duration on legacy contracts alone; without making a single sale. It is possible that many will get acquired, as the companies that do have cash on hand will find many bargains to be found. Acquisitions happen in all economic situations after all. When the news gets this negative it’s often a sign that a bottom may be near. I’m not convinced of that yet, but I think this quarter will give us a pretty good indication of what 2009 will bring.

–jeremy

  • Share/Bookmark

MySQL: Now and Then… and Dual License Community Impact

Stephen O’Grady recently posted a Q&A pertaining to the past, present, and future of MySQL. There’s been quite a bit going on at MySQL and Sun lately, but I’ll focus on one issue in this post – the impact of the current MySQL dual-licensing strategy. Stephen covers much more in his post, and I will be posting some additional MySQL-related thoughts soon. From the linked post:

A: Well, let’s remember what the dual license mechanism is and how it works. Here’s a basic description I wrote a while back:

A single entity such as MySQL is responsible for the overwhelming majority of all development on a given codebase. Anything they don’t produce themselves, they license. Very often this is practiced in conjunction with the dual-license model; because MySQL is responsible for virtually all of the development of the core code, they own or have licensed appropriately all of the involved IP. As such, they’re free to issue commercial licenses to those who would cannot or choose not to comply with the terms of the open source license – the GPL, in this case.

Generally, this model has served MySQL fairly well. By controlling the intellectual property, they retain the rights to relicense the code, thus protecting a revenue stream. They also were afforded a slightly greater protection from forks versus more collaboratively developed projects like Linux, in that they – theoretically – employed the majority of the people qualified and paid to work on the codebase at the lowest levels. But let’s come back to that.

What’s the catch to the model? In part, it’s that the burden of development is born almost entirely by the MySQL staff, but the more relevant concern here is the inability to consume external contributions – even if they’re excellent – without licensing them.

Stated more simply: as long as MySQL remains committed to the dual licensing model, it will be unable to accept the same patch set that open source only versions of the code can, because they do not share the same licensing concerns. Which is why we’ve seen these spring up, and possibly why the MySQL-derived Drizzle project has taken a different approach from its parent.

For a long time, most viewed the control that MySQL AB had as a strength, at least from a business perspective. With the high quality work that is now going on outside MySQL/Sun, however, that is increasingly not the case. Percona, Proven Scaling, OurDelta, Google and others are doing some really cool things these days. The current thinking for many is that the best bang for the buck when it comes to MySQL is now outside MySQL. That’s never happened before and I think it shifts the entire MySQL landscape. The question for Sun now becomes: when will the ability to consume external contributions outweigh the perceived benefits of the dual-license strategy that inhibits the consumption of those contributions? While Drizzle may change some of this, I think it’s a question Sun is going to have to answer (for its own good) sooner… rather than later.

–jeremy

  • Share/Bookmark

MySQL licensing redux

A follow up to one of the more divisive announcements made at the MySQL Conference. From the 451 Group Blog:

After all the fuss it appears that MySQL will be remaining open source after all. As Kaj Arno and Monty Widenius report, Marten Mickos announced at CommunityOne that the MySQL Server will stay open source, as well as the forthcoming encryption and compression backup features, which MySQL had considered making available only to paying customers.

“The change comes from MySQL now being part of Sun Microsystems. Our initial plans were made for a company considering an IPO, but made less sense in the context of Sun, a large company with a whole family of complementary open source software and hardware products,” writes Kaj.

“My hope is that the experiment when it comes to closed source extensions developed by Sun is now ended. As far as I know, there is no existing plans for any closed source extensions to the MySQL server,” adds Monty.

While that seems pretty clear cut, there is still room for a little confusion. Kaj writes: “To financially support MySQL’s free and open source platform, we have a business model which allows both community and commercial add-ons, and we remain committed to it.”

Monty clarifies: “I interpret this, in the context of Mårten’s and Jonathan’s announcements, that we will continue to support and make available commercial addons to the MySQL server from third party, like the Infobright storage engine. Things that we develop ourselves at Sun, at least on the server, will continue to be open source.”

It was always made clear that the decision to ship closed extensions was made before the Sun acquisition. It’s good to see that Sun stepped up, listened to feedback and changed this. It may have made sense for a company looking to IPO, but it doesn’t make sense for Sun. While it’s now clear that Sun-shipped server code will now be open, they also made it clear that 3rd party commercial extensions will continue to be embraced. I see that as a good thing. The “at least on the server” qualifier does leave the door open for something on the MySQL periphery to be closed, but that’s been the case for a few years now (MySQL Monitor for instance). If you’d like to know more about the announcement, Monty has posted his opinion:

I was yesterday attending the “Open Tuesday” Sun & MySQL event. One of the first questions I got from the audience during my questions & answer session was what is my take of the recent MySQL proposition of having closed source parts/modules in the server.

I was very happy to be able to say that Mårten some hours earlier had announced on CommuntyOne that the MySQL server is and is always going to be open source.

It’s very good to see that Mårten is continuing to be responsive to the MySQL community and to the MySQL customers. Thanks to Mårten for doing the right thing! Thanks to the MySQL community for expressing their opinions!

Monty also posted a very good (and honest) assesment of the MySQL Conference here.

–jeremy

  • Share/Bookmark

The OpenSolaris Community v2: Prepare Yourself

Sun is a company I plan on covering a bit more as they continue to delve deeper into Open Source. I’ve commented on the current messaging issue Sun has around its Open Source participation previously. I haven’t been following Open Solaris as much as I’d have liked, but this post by Ben gets you up to speed on the current situation:

Ian Murdock’s distro formly known as “Indiana” will be birthed as “OpenSolaris” in less than a week, being debuted at CommunityOne on May 5th. This will be a major landmark even in the history of Solaris, right up there with the BSD-to-SysV transition and release of the code. There is no talk at Sun regarding Solaris 11, when pushed the only quote I get is “over my dead body”, apparently coming from high within the organization. While no one will clarify on the situation, the current vibe seems to be that Solaris 10 will be with us for a very long time, in update purgatory, while the future revolves around the OpenSolaris distribution. Ultimately the decision will probly be made by Sun’s attempts to get ISV’s behind OpenSolaris… but this is only my hunch, I’ll continue pushing Sun to clarify the roadmap, perhaps at CommunityOne will learn more.

… Its time for a community reset. With the release of the OpenSolaris distro the last bits of the community started by Andy Tucker and Claire Giordano will be, in my view, gone away. The experiment in community official ended and replaced. Rather than the community being joint owners of Solaris it will be affirmed that Sun is firmly staying at the helm and we’re free to board the train and pitch in if we choose. Those of us fighting against the tide are now presented with a choice… give up and try to re-invent our roles in the “new reality” or continue to fight the inevitable like so many of those in our community who still whine if an OS doesn’t run on an i386 with 512K of RAM looking like a senile prick.

It seems clear to me that Sun is not going to give up full control of Open Solaris. To be fair, Red Hat didn’t go as open with Fedora as was initially assumed either. In the end, much of it comes down to how Sun perceives Solaris driving its bottom line. It used to be that Solaris sold expensive SPARC hardware. That’s not as much the case any more. Where that leaves Solaris is unclear to me. Sun is still driving innovation – you need look no further than DTrace and ZFS to see evidence of that. Does that sell enough Sun hardware to justify the engineering costs associated with Solaris? I don’t know, but at some point Sun is going to have to look very at that question and they may not like the answer they get.

While catching up on Open Solaris, I also came across two good posts by Ted. In What Sun was trying to do with Open Solaris he looks into what kinds of participation Sun was originally looking for when they launched Open Solaris. His Organic vs. Non-organic Open Source follow up delves into a Brian Aker comment about projects moving between “organic” and “non-organic” (or in the case of Solaris->Open Solaris, moving between proprietary and either organic/non-organic Open Source). These kind of issues are going to be getting more and more scrutiny if I had to guess, as more and more commercial Open Source companies are going to have to figure out their business models and hit revenue goals. The commercial Open Source space is starting to mature, and I don’t think some people are going to like it.

–jeremy

  • Share/Bookmark

Sun and Open Source

Sun takes a lot of heat in the community. Some would say too much, others would say not enough. I find the situation fascinating, really… and think it’s a good look into the complex and sometimes antithetical nature of the Open Source ecosystem. I don’t think it’s disputable the Sun has done a ton for Open Source. They have deep roots in OSS and to this day contribute a ton of code and mindshare. They have strayed off the path a bit at times and I think part of the uneasiness has to do with their waffling opinion on Linux. To me, it seems like much of this is in the past, but reputations die hard. One thing that is not in the past, and is the current cause of some consternation, is that Sun likes to control projects more then some in the Open Source world are willing to tolerate. The did it with Java, OOo and now OpenSolaris. Roy Fielding recently stepped down from the OpenSolaris project due to this and I think he brings up some valid concerns. I also think much of the problem Sun has in this regard isn’t how they act, but is around their messaging. As Roy mentioned in his email, companies like MySQL were able to adopt products that are truly Open Source with a decision making structure that was mostly controlled within the company. Not many people gave MySQL heat about that, because they were quite up front and transparent about it. Sun is not always so. My next point, as you may have guessed, is that with the recent MySQL AB acquisition, Sun has the opportunely to study and learn from the culture that MySQL was able to create. While I still have some concerns, the more I think about the deal the more I think it made a ton of sense for Sun.

While on the topic of Sun and Open Source, it would be hard to not mention the dust kicked up recently by this post. I do have some commentary, but will save it for a future post. I will say now that I do have some concerns that Sun will be tempted to push MySQL on Solaris, but I don’t think Linux support of MySQL will suffer any time soon. If you’d like some background on the Linux and OpenSolaris issue, this is a great post for you.

–jeremy

  • Share/Bookmark

What Makes a Freedom Fighter Join a Giant? or Ten Reasons to Get Acquired

An interesting inside look on what went into the MySQL end of the acquisition decision from Mårten Mickos has recently been posted.

At MySQL there were few things we loved as much as the thought of being our own masters. We had always been contrarians and we prided ourselves with not following what we saw as outdated ideas from big companies. We made the dolphin on our logo jump surprisingly from right to left (as opposed to the typical left to right) – because we wanted it to be clear: we were not afraid to be different. We decided that people can work from home so we can hire the best and brightest anywhere in the world – not just Stockholm, Seattle or Silicon Valley. We cherished heated debates in the company – and there were many. When other companies dictated alignment, we celebrated dissonance and accepted that there could be multiple viewpoints. When others gathered their staff at a prestigious hotel somewhere in the USA, we summoned our engineers to a primitive sanatorium outside St. Petersburg, Russia. We did it our way. At times it was difficult –even chaotic, but we loved it even more for that reason. It created a passion and strength inside the company.

So why did we change our minds in a few short weeks? What made us think that Sun Microsystems would be a good home for us? What made this better than an IPO? Why did we abandon our revolution for a stable nation? What was it in Sun Microsystems that attracted us? And, most importantly, will we be able to maintain the passion that has driven us to where we are today?

Let me start in a typical Scandinavian contrarian way: Perhaps we will be unable to maintain our passion within Sun. And at the most extreme, perhaps we should not have done this deal. The reality is it will take many years before we can judge this decision to know if it was the right course.

But let me also state that there is probably no better place for this “dirty dozen” (or perhaps “fanatical four hundred”) of MySQL than inside Sun Microsystems.

I’ve always really liked and had a huge amount of respect for both Mårten and the MySQL founders. They built a great company and a great product, and have been open and transparent the entire time. How this acquisition pans out has huge implications for Open Source IMHO. MySQL AB was on target to become one of the largest pure play Open Source companies in the world. With more and more Open Source companies being scooped up by traditional players and consolidators, it remains unclear to me how many pure play Open Source companies we’ll see in 5+ years. I think the ramifications of that are still not well understood (or given enough attention for that matter). Only time will tell.

–jeremy

  • Share/Bookmark



oem office xp software Purchase Computer Software iCorrect EditLab Pro 4.52 software oem cd line business Buy Acrobat adobe cs2 photo shop total training microsoft office 2003 oem; Buy Excel Software locate software oem files widows oem software Adobe Illustrator Downloads Window 2000 upgrade download window 2003 900. "quark xpress 6 crack" Buy Anti Virus Software oem software bundle software oem italiano Software Engineer adobe photo shop element oem software cds Used Quicken Software microsoft window 2000 professional oem software cheap software downloads Buy Windows Software oem Microsoft Office Adobe standard encoding adobe standard oem download 89. Nero Download oem office 2000 software upgrade window 2000 to xp, Buy Microsoft Frontpage 2002 dvd to pocket pc 1.2.4 inkjet definition oem software Buy 3dsmax The Logo Creator MEGA pak 3.6 financial planning software australia Nero Buy cheap PhotoShop CS 2 how to activate reget deluxe Microsoft Office 2003 software oem cd line business

adobe cs2 photo shop total training

Steinberg Cubase microsoft office 2003 oem; Legal oem software legal oem software downloads 585. Buy Photoshop 7.0 widows oem software Window 2000 upgrade download window 2003 900. Modeling Software "quark xpress 6 crack" oem software bundle Dreamweaver Software software oem italiano adobe photo shop element Buy Windows oem software cds microsoft window 2000 professional oem software Windows 2003 Server Price cheap software downloads oem Microsoft Office Point Of Purchase Software Adobe standard encoding adobe standard oem download 89. oem office 2000 software Microsoft Excel 2000 Software upgrade window 2000 to xp,
dvd to pocket pc 1.2.4 Acrobat Adobe Reader inkjet definition oem software
student discount adobe cs Where Can I Buy Photoshop financial planning software australia Buy cheap After Effects 5.5 Production Bundle Cakewalk Sonar 3 iCorrect EditLab Pro 4.52 software oem cd line business Home Design Software adobe cs2 photo shop total training microsoft office 2003 oem; Archicad 9 locate software oem files widows oem software Buy Microsoft Office 2000 Window 2000 upgrade download window 2003 900. "quark xpress 6 crack" Microsoft Frontpage 2002 oem software bundle software oem italiano Buy Acrobat 7.0 adobe photo shop element oem software cds Autocad Download microsoft window 2000 professional oem software cheap software downloads Home Inspection Report Software oem Microsoft Office Adobe Standard! Windows Xp Professional oem office 2000 software upgrade window 2000 to xp, How To Use Photoshop Elements 6 dvd to pocket pc 1.2.4 inkjet definition oem software Purchase Photoshop Cs2 The Logo Creator MEGA pak 3.6 financial planning software australia Cheap Creative Suite Buy cheap PhotoShop CS 2 iCorrect EditLab Pro 4.52 Buy Hardware And Software software oem cd line business adobe cs2 photo shop total training Buy Photoshop Cheap microsoft office 2003 oem; locate software oem files Ahead Nero Gratis widows oem software Window 2000 upgrade download window 2003 900. Cheap Software Prices For You "quark xpress 6 crack" oem software bundle Download Microsoft Outlook software oem italiano adobe photo shop element Mcafee Siteadvisor oem software cds microsoft window 2000 professional oem software Microsoft 2000

cheap software downloads

oem full version game Buy Acrobat Professional Adobe standard encoding adobe standard oem download 89. oem office 2000 software Calculator Software upgrade window 2000 to xp, dvd to pocket pc 1.2.4 Microsoft Access inkjet definition oem software The Logo Creator MEGA pak 3.6 Microsoft Office Xp financial planning software australia

Buy cheap PhotoShop CS 2

Student Discount Software San Diego iCorrect EditLab Pro 4.52 software discount oem

Buy Microsoft Office Software

adobe cs2 photo shop total training Mcafee all in 1 2006, Download Macromedia locate software oem files widows oem software Buy Microsoft Project Window 2000 upgrade download window 2003 900. "quark xpress 6 crack" Cakewalk oem software bundle software oem italiano Adobe Photoshop Express adobe photo shop element oem software buys Microsoft Visual Basic 6.0 Professional Software Cheap Used microsoft window 2000 professional oem software cheap software downloads Microsoft Outlook Download oem Microsoft Office Adobe standard encoding adobe standard oem download 89. Buy Antivirus Software
oem office 2000 software trance xpansion Buy Microsoft Office Professional dvd to pocket pc 1.2.4 inkjet definition oem software Game Design Software The Logo Creator MEGA pak 3.6 financial planning software australia Buy Auto Cad Buy cheap PhotoShop CS 2 iCorrect EditLab Pro 4.52 Used Adobe Flash Software software oem cd line business adobe cs2 photo shop total training Purchase Photoshop Cs3 microsoft office 2003 oem; locate software oem files Microsoft Office 2003 Student widows oem software Window 2000 upgrade download window 2003 900. Nero 8 "quark xpress 6 crack" oem software bundle Cisco Vpn software oem italiano adobe photo shop element Microsoft Front Page oem software cds microsoft window 2000 professional oem software Microsoft Frontpage cheap software downloads oem Microsoft Office Creative Suite Price Adobe standard encoding adobe standard oem download 89. oem office 2000 software Mcafee Antivirus upgrade window 2000 to xp, download worm armageddon full version Best Buy Adobe Photoshop inkjet definition oem software The Logo Creator MEGA pak 3.6 Buy Adobe Acrobat Standard financial planning software australia Buy cheap PhotoShop CS 2 Buy Autocad 2002 iCorrect EditLab Pro 4.52 software oem cd line business Adobe Photoshop Elements For Mac adobe cs2 photo shop total training microsoft office 2003 oem; Adobe Photoshop Cs 8.0 Download
locate software oem files
uk software oem frontpage? Microsoft Outlook Express 7 Window 2000 upgrade download window 2003 900. "quark xpress 6 crack" Buy Windows Xp oem software bundle software oem italiano Purchase Indesign adobe photo shop element oem software cds Microsoft Used Software microsoft window 2000 professional oem software cheap software downloads Macromedia Flash oem Microsoft Office Adobe standard encoding adobe standard oem download 89. Buy Autocad 2004 oem office 2000 software upgrade window 2000 to xp, Microsoft Outlook To Mac dvd to pocket pc 1.2.4 inkjet definition oem software Corel Draw Download The Logo Creator MEGA pak 3.6 financial planning software australia Purchase Windows 98 Buy cheap PhotoShop CS 2 iCorrect EditLab Pro 4.52 Adobe Software software oem cd line business adobe cs2 photo shop total training

Microsoft Office 2003 Professional

microsoft office 2003 oem; Legal oem software legal oem software downloads 585. 3d Studio Max Download widows oem software Window 2000 upgrade download window 2003 900. Software Purchases "quark xpress 6 crack" oem software bundle

Cheap Software Microsoft Publisher

software oem italiano adobe photo shop cs 2 Corel Wordperfect oem software cds microsoft office software oem Buy Adobe Premiere cheap software downloads oem Microsoft Office Macromedia Flash Mx Pro 2004 Download Adobe standard encoding adobe standard oem download 89. oem nero software Adobe Photoshop Elements 6 For Mac upgrade window 2000 to xp, download worm armageddon full version Buy Cubase 4 inkjet definition oem software The Logo Creator MEGA pak 3.6 Buy Old Software financial planning software australia Buy cheap PhotoShop CS 2 Microsoft Powerpoint Downloads iCorrect EditLab Pro 4.52 software oem cd line business Download Photoshop Elements adobe cs2 photo shop total training microsoft office 2003 oem; Buy Illustrator Cs3 locate software oem files widows oem software Buy Microsoft Xp Window 2000 upgrade download window 2003 900. "quark xpress 6 crack" Purchasing Photoshop oem software bundle software oem italiano Buy Oem Software adobe photo shop element oem software buys Discount Microsoft Office Software microsoft window 2000 professional oem software cheap software Buy Business Software oem Microsoft Office Adobe standard encoding adobe standard oem download 89. Buy Dreamweaver oem office 2000 software upgrade window 2000 to xp, Buying Pdf dvd to pocket pc 1.2.4
inkjet definition oem software
Okvir Photoshop The Logo Creator MEGA pak 3.6 finance software, Buy Downloadable Software Buy cheap PhotoShop CS 2 iCorrect EditLab Pro 4.52 Purchase Adobe Acrobat 8 software oem cd line business adobe cs2 photo shop total training Autosketch microsoft office 2003 oem; locate software oem files Software Solutions widows oem software Window 2000 upgrade download window 2003 900. Where Can I Purchase Windows Xp Online "quark xpress 6 crack" oem software bundle Windows 2000 Server Price software oem italiano adobe photo shop element Microsoft Outlook Express 6 oem software cds microsoft office software oem Buy Adobe Creative Suite cheap software downloads oem Microsoft Office Acdsee Pro Adobe standard encoding adobe standard oem download 89. oem office 2000 software Cakewalk Iso upgrade window 2000 to xp, dvd to pocket pc 1.2.4 Buy Adobe Acrobat 8 inkjet definition oem software
The Logo Creator MEGA pak 3.6 Adobe Acrobat 7.0 Standard financial planning software australia

Buy cheap After Effects 5.5 Production Bundle

Buy 3ds Max 6 iCorrect EditLab Pro 4.52 software discount oem Purchase Quark adobe cs2 photo shop total training microsoft office 2003 oem; Asobe Photoshop Elements 3 locate software oem files widows oem software Microsoft Visual Studio Window 2000 upgrade download window 2003 900. "quark xpress 6 crack" Macromedia Flash Sale oem software bundle software oem italiano 3d Studio Max adobe photo shop element oem software cds Illustrator Sale microsoft window 2000 professional oem software cheap software Html Software oem Microsoft Office Adobe standard encoding adobe standard oem download 89. Buy Coldfusion oem office 2000 software upgrade window 2000 to xp, Download Macromedia Flash dvd to pocket pc 1.2.4 inkjet definition oem software Norton The Logo Creator MEGA pak 3.6 financial planning software australia Buy Office 2003 Software Buy cheap PhotoShop CS 2 iCorrect EditLab Pro 4.52 Discount Office Software software oem cd line business adobe cs2 photo shop total training Coffeecup microsoft office 2003 oem; locate software oem files Download Adobe Illustrator widows oem software Window 2000 upgrade download window 2003 900. Buy Photoshop Cs "quark xpress 6 crack" oem software bundle Buy Windows Xp Online software oem italiano adobe photo shop element Downloading Software oem software cds microsoft window 2000 professional oem software

Computer Software

cheap software downloads oem full version game Buy Illustrator Adobe standard encoding adobe standard oem download 89. oem office 2000 software Photoshop Cs3 upgrade window 2000 to xp, download worm armageddon full version Adobe Illustrator Cs Download inkjet definition oem software The Logo Creator MEGA pak 3.6 Project Software financial planning software australia Buy cheap PhotoShop CS 2 Cool Software iCorrect EditLab Pro 4.52 software oem cd line business

Buy Windows 2000 Os Cheap

adobe cs2 photo shop total training Mcafee all in 1 2006, Compression Software locate software oem files widows oem software Buy Download Photoshop Window 2000 upgrade download window 2003 900. "quark xpress 6 crack" Download Microsoft Powerpoint oem software bundle software oem italiano Buy Photoshop 7 adobe photo shop element oem software cds Movie Maker Software microsoft window 2000 professional oem software cheap software downloads Download Microsoft Office oem Microsoft Office Adobe standard encoding adobe standard oem download 89. Buy Download Software oem office 2000 software upgrade window 2000 to xp, Macromedia Homesite dvd to pocket pc 1.2.4 inkjet definition oem software Buy Microsoft Front Page The Logo Creator MEGA pak 3.6 financial planning software australia Buy Macromedia Buy cheap PhotoShop CS 2 iCorrect EditLab Pro 4.52 Windows Movie Maker software oem cd line business adobe cs2 photo shop total training Mcafee Virus Scan microsoft office 2003 oem; locate software oem files Software To Buy widows oem software Window 2000 upgrade download window 2003 900. Buy Autocad Mechanical "quark xpress 6 crack" oem software bundle Cheap Software Uk software oem italiano adobe photo shop element Maintenance Software oem software cds microsoft window 2000 professional oem software Windows Xp Store cheap software downloads oem Microsoft Office Adobe Acrobat 9 Adobe standard encoding adobe standard oem download 89. oem microsoft software Buy Adobe Photoshop Cs2 upgrade window 2000 to xp, dvd to pocket pc 1.2.4
Buy Cheap Software Com inkjet definition oem software student discount adobe cs Buy Illustrator Cs financial planning software australia Buy cheap PhotoShop CS 2 Purchase Used Software iCorrect EditLab Pro 4.52 software oem cd line business Purchase Windows Xp adobe cs2 photo shop total training microsoft office 2003 oem;
Mcafee Virusscan
locate software oem files uk software oem frontpage? Photo Software Window 2000 upgrade download window 2003 900. "quark xpress 6 crack" Search Software oem software bundle software oem agreements Maya 3d adobe photo shop element oem software cds Macromedia Dreamweaver 8 microsoft window 2000 professional oem software cheap software downloads Cheap Autocad Software oem Microsoft Office Adobe Standard! Corel Painter oem office 2000 software "Upgrade Version" Microsoft Office 2003 Torrent dvd to pocket pc 1.2.4
inkjet definition oem software
Adobe Acrobat 8 Download The Logo Creator MEGA pak 3.6 finance software, Buy Adobe Illustrator Cs Buy cheap PhotoShop CS 2 how to activate reget deluxe Microsoft Office 2003 Slo Torrents software oem cd line business

adobe cs2 photo shop total training

Frontpage Download microsoft office 2003 oem; Legal oem software legal oem software downloads 585. Buy Adobe Illustrator Cs3 widows oem software window 2000 professional upgrade Adobe Photoshop Elements Download "quark xpress 6 crack" oem software bundle Adobe Photoshop Elements 2 software oem italiano adobe photo shop element Buy Adobe Photoshop oem software cds microsoft window 2000 professional oem software Cakewalk Music Creator cheap software downloads oem Microsoft Office Buy And Download Software Adobe standard encoding adobe standard oem download 89. oem office 2000 software Buy Mac Software upgrade window 2000 to xp, dvd to pocket pc 1.2.4 Buy Nero 8
inkjet definition oem software student discount adobe cs Discount Windows Firewall Software financial planning software australia Buy cheap PhotoShop CS 2

Buy Freehand

iCorrect EditLab Pro 4.52 software discount oem Photoshop Cs adobe cs2 photo shop total training microsoft office 2003 oem; Shop Design Software locate software oem files widows oem software Download Microsoft Excel Window 2000 upgrade download window 2003 900. "quark xpress 6 crack" Illustrator Plugins oem software bundle software oem italiano Autodesk adobe photo shop element oem software buys Bootleg Software Miami Where To Buy microsoft window 2000 professional oem software cheap software Design Software Sale oem Microsoft Office Adobe standard encoding adobe standard oem download 89. Purchase Adobe Acrobat oem office 2000 software upgrade window 2000 to xp, Photoshop Cs .iso dvd to pocket pc 1.2.4 inkjet definition oem software Windows 98 The Logo Creator MEGA pak 3.6 financial planning software australia Buy Windows Xp Professional Buy cheap PhotoShop CS 2 iCorrect EditLab Pro 4.52 Cheap Computer Software software oem cd line business adobe cs2 photo shop total training Sonar Cakewalk microsoft office 2003 oem; locate software oem files Norton Systemworks widows oem software Window 2000 upgrade download window 2003 900. Window Media Player Mp4 Codec "quark xpress 6 crack" oem software bundle Autocad 2005 software oem italiano adobe photo shop element Autodesk Autocad oem software cds microsoft office software oem Buy Cold Fusion cheap software downloads oem Microsoft Office Photoshop Elements 4 For Mac Computer Adobe standard encoding adobe standard oem download 89. oem office 2000 software Statistical Software upgrade window 2000 to xp, download worm armageddon full version Buy Microsoft Windows Server 2003 inkjet definition oem software The Logo Creator MEGA pak 3.6 Where To Buy Photoshop financial planning software australia Buy cheap PhotoShop CS 2 Buy Illustrator Cs2 iCorrect EditLab Pro 4.52 software oem cd line business Autodesk Impression adobe cs2 photo shop total training microsoft office 2003 oem; Buy Software In Canada locate software oem files widows oem software Microsoft Office 2000 Premium Window 2000 upgrade download window 2003 900. "quark xpress 6 crack" Ahead Nero 7 Download oem software bundle software oem italiano Adobe Premiere adobe photo shop element oem software cds Adobe Photoshop Cheap microsoft window 2000 professional oem software cheap software Autocad 2000 oem Microsoft Office Adobe standard encoding adobe standard oem download 89. Best Buy Software oem office 2000 software upgrade window 2000 to xp, Where To Buy Adobe Photoshop dvd to pocket pc 1.2.4 inkjet definition oem software Design Software Price The Logo Creator MEGA pak 3.6 financial planning software australia Download Adobe Acrobat Buy cheap PhotoShop CS 2 iCorrect EditLab Pro 4.52 Academic Discount Software software oem cd line business adobe cs2 photo shop total training

Acrobat Download

microsoft office 2003 oem; Legal oem software legal oem software downloads 585. Buy Indesign Cs2 widows oem software Window 2000 upgrade download window 2003 900. Software At Best Buy "quark xpress 6 crack" oem software bundle

Autocad 2000 Navodila

software oem italiano adobe photo shop cs 2 Pyro Cakewalk oem software cds microsoft window 2000 professional oem software Purchase Microsoft Software cheap software downloads oem Microsoft Office Autocad Light Adobe standard encoding adobe standard oem download 89. oem office 2000 software Video Editing Software upgrade window 2000 to xp, dvd to pocket pc 1.2.4 Download Microsoft Word inkjet definition oem software The Logo Creator MEGA pak 3.6 Buy Cubase financial planning software australia Buy cheap PhotoShop CS 2 Coffeecup Software iCorrect EditLab Pro 4.52 software oem cd line business Microsoft Publisher adobe cs2 photo shop total training microsoft office 2003 oem; Microsoft Office locate software oem files widows oem software Visio Discount Software Oem Window 2000 upgrade download window 2003 900. "quark xpress 6 crack" Autocad Inventor oem software bundle software oem agreements Where To Buy Windows Xp adobe photo shop element oem software cds Older Discount Computer Software microsoft window 2000 professional oem software cheap software downloads Media Software oem Microsoft Office Adobe standard encoding adobe standard oem download 89. Corel Painter X oem office 2000 software upgrade window 2000 to xp, Windows Xp Home Edition dvd to pocket pc 1.2.4 inkjet definition oem software Corel Paint Shop Pro The Logo Creator MEGA pak 3.6 financial planning software australia Microsoft Office Powerpoint Download Buy cheap PhotoShop CS 2 iCorrect EditLab Pro 4.52 Cisco Ip Phone software oem cd line business adobe cs2 photo shop total training Microsoft Powerpoint Viewer microsoft office 2003 oem; locate software oem files Purchase Photoshop 7 widows oem software Window 2000 upgrade download window 2003 900. Adobe Acrobat 6.0 Download "quark xpress 6 crack" oem software bundle Quark Sale software oem italiano adobe photo shop element Dreamweaver Mx Used Software oem software cds microsoft window 2000 professional oem software Buy Microsoft Office 2007

cheap software downloads

oem full version game Buy Powerpoint Software Adobe standard encoding adobe standard oem download 89. oem office 2000 software Buy Autocad Lt upgrade window 2000 to xp, dvd to pocket pc 1.2.4 Software Student Discount inkjet definition oem software The Logo Creator MEGA pak 3.6 Purchase 3ds Max financial planning software australia Buy cheap PhotoShop CS 2 Macromedia Studio 8 iCorrect EditLab Pro 4.52 software oem cd line business Adobe Acrobat adobe cs2 photo shop total training microsoft office 2003 oem; Macromedia Studio 8 Price locate software oem files widows oem software Microsoft Frontpage Xp Window 2000 upgrade download window 2003 900. "quark xpress 6 crack" Powerpoint Software oem software bundle software oem italiano Buy Cheep Software adobe photo shop element oem software cds Autocad 2008 microsoft window 2000 professional oem software cheap software downloads Buy Cubase Sx oem Microsoft Office Adobe standard encoding adobe standard oem download 89. Discount Adobe Software oem office 2000 software upgrade window 2000 to xp, Buy Adobe Photoshop Cs dvd to pocket pc 1.2.4 inkjet definition oem software Hotdocs Software Discount The Logo Creator MEGA pak 3.6 financial planning software australia Web Site Software Buy cheap PhotoShop CS 2 iCorrect EditLab Pro 4.52 Microsoft Outlook Express software oem cd line business adobe cs2 photo shop total training Buy Autocad microsoft office 2003 oem; locate software oem files Photoshop Download widows oem software Window 2000 upgrade download window 2003 900. Buy Ms Frontpage "quark xpress 6 crack" oem software bundle Download Software Discount software oem italiano adobe photo shop element Creative Suite 3 oem software cds microsoft window 2000 professional oem software Discount Computer Software cheap software downloads oem Microsoft Office Ahead Nero 7 Adobe standard encoding adobe standard oem download 89. oem office 2000 software Adobe Photoshop Elements 5.0 Quick Notes upgrade window 2000 to xp, dvd to pocket pc 1.2.4 Adobe Acrobat Pro 8 inkjet definition oem software The Logo Creator MEGA pak 3.6
Utility Software financial planning software australia Buy cheap After Effects 5.5 Production Bundle

Ahead Software

iCorrect EditLab Pro 4.52 software discount oem Adobe Cs3 Flash Assignments adobe cs2 photo shop total training microsoft office 2003 oem; Money Software locate software oem files widows oem software Adobe Acrobat Reader Window 2000 upgrade download window 2003 900. "quark xpress 6 crack" Purchase Microsoft Office Software oem software bundle software oem italiano Purchase Adobe Photoshop Cs2 adobe photo shop element oem software cds Acdsee 10 microsoft window 2000 professional oem software cheap software downloads Download Adobe Acrobat Reader oem Microsoft Office Adobe standard encoding adobe standard oem download 89. Buy Adobe Acrobat Professional oem office 2000 software upgrade window 2000 to xp, Buy Nero dvd to pocket pc 1.2.4 inkjet definition oem software Discount Software The Logo Creator MEGA pak 3.6 financial planning software australia Ahead Software Nero Buy cheap PhotoShop CS 2 iCorrect EditLab Pro 4.52 Photoshop Elements 2 software oem cd line business adobe cs2 photo shop total training Microsoft Windows microsoft office 2003 oem; locate software oem files Autodesk 3d Studio Max widows oem software Window 2000 upgrade download window 2003 900. Buy Autodesk Viz "quark xpress 6 crack" oem software bundle Adobe Acrobat Reader 8 software oem italiano adobe photo shop element Buy Design Software oem software cds microsoft window 2000 professional oem software Adobe Acrobat Rider cheap software downloads oem Microsoft Office Good Software Adobe standard encoding adobe standard oem download 89. oem office 2000 software Norton Symantec upgrade window 2000 to xp, dvd to pocket pc 1.2.4 Buy Windows Operating System inkjet definition oem software The Logo Creator MEGA pak 3.6 Archicad Download financial planning software australia Buy cheap PhotoShop CS 2 Microsoft Powerpoint iCorrect EditLab Pro 4.52 software oem cd line business Buy 3ds Max 7 adobe cs2 photo shop total training microsoft office 2003 oem; Macromedia Flash 8 Download locate software oem files widows oem software Windows 2000 Price Window 2000 upgrade download window 2003 900. "quark xpress 6 crack" Norton Antivirus oem software bundle software oem italiano Adobe Acrobat Torrent adobe photo shop element oem software cds Microsoft Office 2007 Enterprise microsoft window 2000 professional oem software cheap software downloads Microsoft Office Enterprise oem Microsoft Office Adobe standard encoding adobe standard oem download 89. Software Purchase oem office 2000 software upgrade window 2000 to xp, Adobe Photoshop dvd to pocket pc 1.2.4 inkjet definition oem software Downloadable Software The Logo Creator MEGA pak 3.6 financial planning software australia Software Used Buy cheap PhotoShop CS 2