« The problem with disruption
Linux Foundation Collaboration Summit »

Microsoft takes on the free world

Published by
jeremy
at May 14, 2007 in GPLv3, Linux, MSFT, Microsoft, Novell and Open Source.

Some thought it was inevitable, while other thought it would never happen. From a recent Fortune article:

Free software is great, and corporate America loves it. It’s often high-quality stuff that can be downloaded free off the Internet and then copied at will. It’s versatile - it can be customized to perform almost any large-scale computing task - and it’s blessedly crash-resistant.

A broad community of developers, from individuals to large companies like IBM, is constantly working to improve it and introduce new features. No wonder the business world has embraced it so enthusiastically: More than half the companies in the Fortune 500 are thought to be using the free operating system Linux in their data centers.

But now there’s a shadow hanging over Linux and other free software, and it’s being cast by Microsoft. The Redmond behemoth asserts that one reason free software is of such high quality is that it violates more than 200 of Microsoft’s patents. And as a mature company facing unfavorable market trends and fearsome competitors like Google, Microsoft is pulling no punches: It wants royalties. If the company gets its way, free software won’t be free anymore.

The conflict pits Microsoft and its dogged CEO, Steve Ballmer, against the “free world” - people who believe software is pure knowledge. The leader of that faction is Richard Matthew Stallman, a computer visionary with the look and the intransigence of an Old Testament prophet.

Then come the details:

Microsoft counters that it is a matter of principle. “We live in a world where we honor, and support the honoring of, intellectual property,” says Ballmer in an interview. FOSS patrons are going to have to “play by the same rules as the rest of the business,” he insists. “What’s fair is fair.”

Microsoft General Counsel Brad Smith and licensing chief Horacio Gutierrez sat down with Fortune recently to map out their strategy for getting FOSS users to pay royalties. Revealing the precise figure for the first time, they state that FOSS infringes on no fewer than 235 Microsoft patents.

The 235 number is fairly close to the previously given (and disputed) 228. While the lengthy article does get some minor details wrong, it’s a good way to get up to date on the situation if it’s not one you’ve been following. On to why Microsoft choose to do this now. It could be that they think the GPLv3 has teeth and are trying to get out ahead of its release. It could be that they’ve not been as effective as they thought they’d be at battling Open Source and Linux more directly. Regardless of the reason, I agree with Larry:

If Microsoft believes that Free and Open Source Software violates any of their patents, let them put those patents forward now, in the light of day, where we can all evaluate them on their merits. If not, then stop trying to bully customers into paying royalties to use Open Source. It’s time for Microsoft to put up or shut up.

(Tim put it nice and succinctly: Four Words for Microsoft: Litigate or shut up

It appears that the battle lines are being drawn and the cold war of software patent world may be coming to an end. The players involved here are huge and the amount of money astronomical. Who has the most to lose? I’d say Microsoft. How will this play out? We’ll all be watching closely, that’s for sure. One has to wonder how Novell feels about their recent deal right about now.

–jeremy

No TweetBacks yet. (Be the first to Tweet this post)
  • Share/Save/Bookmark

2 Responses to “Microsoft takes on the free world”

Feed for this Entry Trackback Address
  1. 1 winkydo
    May 14th, 2007 at 10:58 am

    interesting that about a year ago microsoft launched Port25.

    http://port25.technet.com

    i would like to be a fly on the wall in a novell board meeting. i’m wandering if they have been contacted or where contacted by the open invention network before the patent deal went down last fall, and if there has been any ‘i told you so’ responses from the industry, not just the blogosphere.

  1. 1 Microsoft and the ‘Do More Evil’ Slogan - Untwisted Vortex
    Pingback on Jul 22nd, 2007 at 1:34 pm

Leave a Reply

You must login to post a comment.

« The problem with disruption
Linux Foundation Collaboration Summit »
discovery health weight loss challenge Phentermine No Prescrition pure lac resin azalee resin flatware? Cinnamon And Honey For Weight Loss bee pollen weight loss curves weight loss center Cori Weight Loss unique resin architectural window frame; clarksville tn weight loss Unique Resin Picture Frames weight loss feeling cold dottys weight loss zone; Plastic Resin Prices treadmill weight loss workouts cinnamon and honey for weight loss Ingredients Adipex weight loss influences and body image weight loss phen Tree Resin Buying unique resin picture frames quick weight loss sauna Acrylic Resin With Risk Phrases discounted adipex quick ship phentermine Healthy Weight Loss Meals nordette and weight loss!

perricone weight loss diet

Adipex Success phentermine heart murmur loss of father inspirational words Exercises For Weight Loss silver with resin phentermine zoloft Weight Loss Kevin Trudeau phentermine zoloft yoga for weight loss greensboro Cenecal For Weight Loss tanisha cater adipex? ex lax weight loss Weight Loss Supplement Ratings barbarian resin statue; weight loss meal replacement Michael Thurmond Weight Loss Program drastic weight loss methods Ramadan weight loss msds acrylic composite resin 696. Weight Loss And The Hypothalamus Gland pharmacia q sepharose resin major producers of epoxy resin, Ho Resin Body Slot Cars epoxy resin jewelry, dottys weight loss zone; Fda Approved Weight Loss Pil L bulimia weight loss birth control pills and weight loss Camp Loss Scholarship Summer Weight natural asain weight loss weight loss shake rx Soy Protein Burn Fat specialty resins? weight loss with bupropion Dietary Guidelines For Weight Loss elliptical weight loss hypnosis cd for weight loss
Epoxy Resin Food Safe
pure lac resin general motors weight loss diet? Phentermine Drug Information bee pollen weight loss curves weight loss center Weight Loss By Hypnosis Seattle unique resin architectural window frame; no prescription cheap phentermine? Serious Weight Loss weight loss feeling cold dottys weight loss zone; Weight Loss Studies treadmill weight loss workouts cinnamon and honey for weight loss Salem Resin Pumpkins weight loss influences and body image weight loss phen Weight Loss Camp For Men unique resin picture frames appetite suppressant drinks Ana Weight Loss Tips discounted adipex ultra 90 weight loss pills, Lyco And Weight Loss nordette and weight loss! perricone weight loss diet Rosin Ester Resin phentermine heart murmur urea resins, Childrens Weight Loss Programs silver with resin phentermine zoloft Smoothie For Weight Loss phentermine zoloft yoga for weight loss greensboro Weight Loss Naturally tanisha cater adipex? weight loss control program Duke University Weight Loss

barbarian resin statue;

see no evil resin Recipes To Promote Weight Loss drastic weight loss methods Ramadan weight loss msds acrylic composite resin 696. Weight Loss And Diet News pharmacia q sepharose resin major producers of epoxy resin, Diet Phentermine Tablet epoxy resin jewelry, dottys weight loss zone; Birth Control Weight Loss bulimia weight loss heart damage from fast weight loss? Taipei Taiwan Weight Loss Pill natural asain weight loss weight loss shake rx 3 Day Diet Loss Weight specialty resins? weight loss with bupropion Ionamin Capsule elliptical weight loss hypnosis cd for weight loss Weight Loss Dairy pure lac resin azalee resin flatware? Breast Cancer And Weight Loss bee pollen weight loss curves weight loss center Bulk Order Of Phentermine unique resin architectural window frame; no prescription cheap phentermine? Weight Loss Products Order Contact weight loss feeling cold dottys weight loss zone; Healthy Diet Weight Loss treadmill weight loss workouts xenical for weight loss Weight Loss While Smoking weight loss influences and body image weight loss phen Pharmacia Q Sepharose Resin unique resin picture frames appetite suppressant drinks Customized Weight Loss discounted adipex quick ship phentermine Fiberglass Resin Wholesale nordette and weight loss! perricone weight loss diet Japanese Secrets For Weight Loss phentermine heart murmur urea resins, Weight Loss Drink Shradhha Sharma silver with resin phentermine zoloft Customhrt Phentermine phentermine zoloft yoga for weight loss greensboro Personal Success Stories Weight Loss tanisha cater adipex? weight loss control program Phentermine Hcl Prescription Diet Pills Information barbarian resin statue; weight loss meal replacement Atipex Phentermine drastic weight loss methods Ramadan weight loss msds acrylic composite resin 696.
Alli Weight Losss pharmacia q sepharose resin "weight loss programs for wrestling" Water Retention And Weight Loss epoxy resin jewelry, dottys weight loss zone; Weight Loss Sweat Suits bulimia weight loss birth control pills and weight loss Hydro Expansive Resin Basement Crack

natural asain weight loss

weight loss clinics in utah Battlestar Galactica Resin Gun specialty resins? weight loss with bupropion

Fat Loss 4 Idoits

elliptical weight loss animated weight loss ticker Weight Loss Barbados pure lac resin azalee resin flatware? Apple Vinegar For Weight Loss bee pollen weight loss curves weight loss center Fitness And Weight Loss unique resin architectural window frame; no prescription cheap phentermine? Amino Acids And Weight Loss weight loss feeling cold dottys weight loss zone; Polishing Clear Resin Parts treadmill weight loss workouts cinnamon and honey for weight loss Weight Loss At 50 weight loss influences and body image weight loss phen Boat Yard Fiberglass Resin unique resin picture frames appetite suppressant drinks Purchase Phentermine No Rx discounted adipex quick ship phentermine The Best Weight Loss Program nordette and weight loss! perricone weight loss diet Celebrity Loss Surgery Weight phentermine heart murmur urea resins, Fast Weight Loss Diet Recipes silver with resin phentermine zoloft Giant Resin Bee phentermine zoloft yoga for weight loss greensboro Buy Phentermine Under The Table tanisha cater adipex? ex lax weight loss Carnie Wilson Weight Loss barbarian resin statue; weight loss meal replacement Weight Loss Surgery For Dummies drastic weight loss methods Ramadan weight loss msds acrylic composite resin 696. Caffeine Pills Weight Loss pharmacia q sepharose resin major producers of epoxy resin,
La Weight Loss Critisism And Wom epoxy resin jewelry, pilates weight loss Weight Loss Bars bulimia weight loss birth control pills and weight loss Personal Weight Loss Journals natural asain weight loss weight loss shake rx

Molding Resin

specialty resins? phentermine worldwide shipping cheapest Weight Loss During Menopause elliptical weight loss hypnosis cd for weight loss
Burn Fat Heart Rate
pure lac resin Weight loss for middle aged women detox and weight loss 393. Azalee Resin Flatware bee pollen weight loss rhodiola weight loss Bogus Phentermine Websites unique resin architectural window frame; no prescription cheap phentermine? Epoxy Resin Floor Screeds Uk weight loss feeling cold dottys weight loss zone; Phentermine Heart Murmur treadmill weight loss workouts xenical for weight loss Symptoms Of Morphine Withdrawal Weight Loss weight loss influences and body image weight loss phen Phentermine No Prescription Saturday Delivery unique resin picture frames appetite suppressant drinks Paramex Weight Loss Review discounted adipex quick ship phentermine Bible Study For Weight Loss Support nordette and weight loss! hypnotherapy weight loss seattle, Acrylonitrile Styrene Plastic Resin Msds phentermine heart murmur urea resins, Detox Diet Weight Loss silver with resin phentermine zoloft Weight Loss Shakes Programs phentermine zoloft yoga for weight loss greensboro Weight Loss Food Guide Pyramid tanisha cater adipex? weight loss control program Hypnosis Cd For Weight Loss barbarian resin statue; weight loss meal replacement Weight Loss Central Pa drastic weight loss methods Ramadan weight loss msds acrylic composite resin 696. La Weight Loss Brisbane pharmacia q sepharose resin major producers of epoxy resin, D Loss Vitamin Weight epoxy resin jewelry, dottys weight loss zone; Fda Aproved Weight Loss bulimia weight loss "optifast for weight loss" 1 35 Brown Water Navy Resin natural asain weight loss weight loss shake rx Quick Weight Loss Methods specialty resins? weight loss with bupropion La Weight Loss Critisism Wom elliptical weight loss hypnosis cd for weight loss I Need Phentermine pure lac resin azalee resin flatware? Oolong Tea For Weight Loss bee pollen weight loss curves weight loss center Fast Phentermine Without Rx unique resin architectural window frame; no prescription cheap phentermine? Auto Fiberglass Resin weight loss feeling cold dottys weight loss zone; Weight Loss No Fruit treadmill weight loss workouts cinnamon and honey for weight loss Diet Loss Pill Program Weight weight loss influences and body image weight loss phen Pine Resin unique resin picture frames quick weight loss sauna Nanoparticle Resin discounted adipex quick ship phentermine Hobby Clear Plastic Resin nordette and weight loss! hypnotherapy weight loss seattle, Accupressure And Weight Loss phentermine heart murmur urea resins, Weight Loss Energy Drinks silver with resin phentermine zoloft Buy Phentermine From China Mexico phentermine zoloft yoga for weight loss greensboro Loss Oklahoma Surgery Weight tanisha cater adipex? weight loss control program Weight Loss Strength Training Videos

barbarian resin statue;

see no evil resin The Best Weight Loss Pills
drastic weight loss methods
opaque resin bead
Angelina Jolie Recent Weight Loss pharmacia q sepharose resin "weight loss programs for wrestling" Closed Cell Resin Manufacturer
epoxy resin jewelry, pilates weight loss Amino Acid Fdr Weight Loss bulimia weight loss "optifast for weight loss" Obesity Weight Loss Clinics

natural asain weight loss

weight loss clinics in utah Fat Loss Drugs specialty resins? weight loss with bupropion La Weight Loss Plans elliptical weight loss hypnosis cd for weight loss Prime Resins Epoxy Distributor pure lac resin azalee resin flatware? Fortis Insurance And Weight Loss Surgery bee pollen weight loss curves weight loss center Africa Pharmacy Online Phentermine unique resin architectural window frame; no prescription cheap phentermine? Generic Versions Of Phentermine weight loss feeling cold dottys weight loss zone; Order Phentermine Pills treadmill weight loss workouts cinnamon and honey for weight loss No Prescription Required Phentermine weight loss influences and body image weight loss phen Phentermine And Pregnancy unique resin picture frames quick weight loss sauna Buy Phentermine Online Doctor discounted adipex quick ship phentermine Fiber For Weight Loss nordette and weight loss! perricone weight loss diet Carbohydrate Amp Weight Loss phentermine heart murmur urea resins, Weight Loss Rules silver with resin phentermine zoloft Weight Loss And Hair Loss phentermine zoloft yoga for weight loss greensboro Drugs Weight Loss tanisha cater adipex? weight loss control program General Motors Weight Loss Diet barbarian resin statue; weight loss meal replacement Industrial Resin Uk drastic weight loss methods Ramadan weight loss msds acrylic composite resin 696. Diet Weight Loss Meal Plan pharmacia q sepharose resin major producers of epoxy resin, Phentermine No Prescription Overnight Delivery epoxy resin jewelry, dottys weight loss zone; Oral Herpes And Weight Loss bulimia weight loss birth control pills and weight loss Book Cook Loss Ultimate Weight natural asain weight loss weight loss shake rx Adipex Diet Med specialty resins? weight loss with bupropion Detox And Weight Loss elliptical weight loss hypnosis cd for weight loss Corey Haim Weight Loss pure lac resin azalee resin flatware? Scrape Resin bee pollen weight loss rhodiola weight loss Buy Fastin Online No Presrciption unique resin architectural window frame; clarksville tn weight loss What Causes Weight Loss weight loss feeling cold dottys weight loss zone; Footage On La Weight Loss Closure treadmill weight loss workouts cinnamon and honey for weight loss Stacking Plastic Resin Chairs weight loss influences and body image weight loss phen Dotties Weight Loss Page unique resin picture frames appetite suppressant drinks Comparison Loss Program Weight discounted adipex quick ship phentermine Weight Loss Machines nordette and weight loss! hypnotherapy weight loss seattle,

Weight Loss Causes

phentermine heart murmur loss of father inspirational words D-ribose Weight Loss silver with resin phentermine zoloft Organic Weight Loss phentermine zoloft yoga for weight loss greensboro Cast Resin Transformers Italy tanisha cater adipex? ex lax weight loss Weight Loss Surgery Recipes barbarian resin statue; weight loss meal replacement No Perscription Phentermine drastic weight loss methods Ramadan weight loss msds acrylic composite resin 696. Meridian Weight Loss Pill pharmacia q sepharose resin major producers of epoxy resin, Phentermine Uk Shipping Online epoxy resin jewelry, dottys weight loss zone; Ion Exchange Resin Poly Sulfonate Analysis bulimia weight loss birth control pills and weight loss Motivation For Weight Loss natural asain weight loss weight loss shake rx Buy Diet Online Phentermine Pill Usa specialty resins? weight loss with bupropion Kevin Trudeaus Weight Loss elliptical weight loss hypnosis cd for weight loss Subliminal Weight Loss Cd pure lac resin azalee resin flatware? Phentermine Be C C 30 Mg bee pollen weight loss curves weight loss center Hand Carved Hd Poly Resin Signs unique resin architectural window frame;